 |
| Image: Rich Michalowski/Facebook |
Tourist selfie taken in Los Angeles sparks debate about homelessness and empathy
A picture of a young woman posing in front of a mural on
Sunset Boulevard, Los Angeles, has gone viral, not only for what it does
show, but also for what it doesn't — empathy.
The image that is getting Internet users so riled up was taken by estate agent and Silver Lake resident Rich Michalowski, who posted it to his Facebook page on Sunday with the caption, "Really?"
It shows the woman getting her photo taken by a companion, with her
hands outstretched and a beaming smile on her face, in front of the
mural by artist and author Dallas Clayton, which invites people to
"stand here and think about someone you love." Also in the shot, lying
at her feet, is a homeless man.
Really?
Posted by Rich Michalowski on Sunday, 6 March 2016
Whoever she was thinking about it wasn't the man on the ground behind her.
"The photographer was directing the woman on where to stand, how to
pose and suggested she take off her jacket," Michalowski told website
TakePart. "At one point the photographer directed her to move closer to the homeless man so she could center the photo. They were still at it when I drove away. [sic]"
Most people have condemned the two women for taking the photo.
"There's a certain amount of irony involved in posing for a warm
fuzzy picture while trying not to stand on a homeless man's head," wrote
Patrick Morris on Facebook.
However some have defended the women. "When there is a homeless man
in front of the grocery store camped out asking you for money… most
people still walk right by and do their shopping… so I am not going to
be pissed at these girls for wanting an instagram photo," wrote Crystal
White-VanCleemput.
The artist Dallas Clayton told TakePart that he "felt sorry for everyone involved" when he saw the picture.
"It's unfortunate that any person would have to sleep on the street.
It's unfortunate that someone could be so disconnected that they would
step over someone to take a photograph and also it's unfortunate that
the spectacle of documenting this is easier to discuss and comment on
than the root issue is to solve," he wrote in an email to the website.
Clayton also made an important point about how society as a whole
treats the homeless. "I think a lot of people want to judge others when
they are in situations like this — make comments like 'this is what's
wrong with the world,' but I don't assume the girls in the photo are
cruel or terrible people who hate the homeless or think themselves
better," he wrote. "I just imagine there to be a disconnect, likely a
systemic disconnect that allows someone to move through the day like
that."
This photo many have been taken in L.A. but homelessness is an issue
across the world. Think about how many homeless people you see on the
streets of every U.K. city. Will Michalowski's image make you think
twice about ignoring them?
"If it takes this photograph for you to realise [sic] that [a
disparity between the haves and the have nots exists] I don't imagine
you've been paying attention to society as a whole for the past fifty or
sixty years," Clayton wrote on his Facebook page.
He also announced that he would be giving 100 percent of the proceeds
from a new range of illustrations to an organisation that helps the
homeless.
Lest we not forget!
